Kelleys Island

Situated in Lake Erie within Erie County, this small island community carries a median home price of $384,450 and a price per square foot of $268, reflecting the premium buyers place on waterfront and recreational access. With only 8 active listings currently on the market, inventory remains extremely tight, which is consistent with a permanent population of just 198 residents. The average home size of 1,585 square feet suggests modest, manageable properties suited to seasonal and year-round use alike. An owner-occupied rate of 93.5% points to a stable, committed residential base rather than a heavily investor-driven market. The median household income of $91,875 supports sustained purchasing power among current residents. Families with children are served by the Kelleys Island Local School District. Buyers considering this market should expect limited selection and move quickly when suitable properties appear, given how rarely homes come available on the island.

Market description generated from current MLS and U.S. Census data.